The Taliban have won. Twenty years after the 2001 invasion, the U.S.-backed government in Kabul has fallen. The Afghan president has fled. Taliban leadership, which ran the country in the late 1990s, is now firmly in place within the presidential palace. Thousands are desperate to leave, literally clinging to departing aircraft as they rumble down runways, fearful of what reprisals may come. But after two decades of war, tens of billions spent, hundreds of thousands of lives lost – including more than 2,300 U.S. military personnel – bigger questions have emerged: Is the cost of leaving greater than the cost of staying? And was pulling out the right decision? Those who say “yes” argue that the world is a decidedly different place than it was in 2001, that the mission was never to nation-build, and that continued presence prolonged the violence and distracted energies and resources away from more pressing global challenges, particularly on those centered on China. But those who argue “no” point to the potential for a humanitarian and human rights catastrophe, the ceding of U.S. influence in Central Asia, and the likelihood for another terrorist safe haven. As such, Open to Debate and its host John Donvan examine these competing perspectives in this special timely edition of Agree-to-Disagree: Leaving Afghanistan. First, a conversation with Ahmed Rashid, a Pakistani journalist and best-selling author, who is one of the world’s leading experts on the social and political situations in Pakistan and Afghanistan. His first book, Taliban: Militant Islam, Oil and Fundamentalism in Central Asia, explores the shadowy world of the Taliban and quickly became a #1 New York Times bestseller. Rashid has been called “Pakistan’s best and bravest reporter” (Christopher Hitchens). Then, a competition of ideas: Arguing in favor of leaving is Daniel Markey, Senior Research Professor at Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies. Arguing against leaving is Kori Schake is a senior fellow and the director of foreign and defense policy studies at the American Enterprise Institute (AEI). Emmy award-winning journalist John Donvan is the moderator.
August 22, 2021
Agree To Disagree: Leaving Afghanistan
SHARE
READ NEXT
Newsletter: Is Free Speech Threatened on Campus?
This week: Protests on college campuses: When do student protests require intervention? A closer look at what students would be comfortable saying on campus Debates to help navigate the most complex questions on the Middle…
April 29, 2024
Ban the Box Newsletter: Should We Banish the Criminal History Check Box from Job Applications?
ARGUING YES Beth Avery Senior Staff Attorney at the National Employment Law Project ARGUING NO Jennifer Doleac Executive Vice President of Criminal Justice at Arnold Ventures MODERATOR John Donvan Host and Moderator-in-Chief …
April 23, 2024
Newsletter: Should Congress Stop Funding the War in Ukraine?
This week: New episode: Should Congress authorize more money to help Ukraine fight Russia? A closer look at how aid to Ukraine compares to other U.S. spending Your Sunday reading list In step…
April 15, 2024
Newsletter: Is Religion a Force for Good?
ARGUING YES Shadi Hamid Columnist and Editorial Board Member of The Washington Post; Assistant Research Professor of Islamic Studies at Fuller Seminary ARGUING NO Annie Laurie Gaylor Co-Founder and Co-President of the Freedom From…
April 5, 2024
Childhood Obesity Guidelines Newsletter: Good Medicine or Too Extreme?
ARGUING “GOOD MEDICINE” Dr. Julia Nordgren Pediatric Lipid Specialist at Palo Alto Medical Foundation; Attending Physician at the Stanford Weight Clinic ARGUING “TOO EXTREME” Dr. Janna Gewirtz O'Brien Pediatrician and Assistant Professor at the…
April 1, 2024
Revisiting the Debate: Should TikTok Be Banned in the U.S.?
ARGUING YES Kori Schake Senior Fellow and Director of Foreign and Defense Policy Studies at the American Enterprise Institute ARGUING NO Milton Mueller Professor at the Georgia Institute of Technology School of Public Policy;…
March 22, 2024
Newsletter: Does Taylor Swift Deserve Her Billion Dollar Fortune?
ARGUING YES Jessica Flanigan Political Philosopher and Chair in Ethics and Democratic Values at the University of Richmond ARGUING NO Ingrid Robeyns Chair in Ethics of Institutions at Utrecht University's Ethics Institute; Author of…
March 18, 2024
Newsletter: Should We Address the Gender Wage Gap?
ARGUING YES Kadie Ward Chief Administrative Officer and Commissioner at the Pay Equity Commission of Ontario ARGUING NO Allison Schrager Economist; Bloomberg Opinion Contributor; Senior Fellow at the Manhattan Institute GUEST MODERATOR Nayeema…
March 11, 2024
Newsletter: Has Citizens United Undermined Democracy?
ARGUING YES Francesca Procaccini Assistant Professor of Law at Vanderbilt University Law School ARGUING YES Ciara Torres-Spelliscy Professor of Law at Stetson University ARGUING NO Floyd Abrams Senior Counsel at Cahill Gordon &…
March 5, 2024
Newsletter on Color Blindness
ARGUING YES Jamelle Bouie Columnist for The New York Times ARGUING NO Coleman Hughes Host of the “Conversations with Coleman” podcast, Contributing Writer at The Free Press, and Analyst at CNN …
February 26, 2024
Unresolved: The Iran Threat
Ray Takeyh Senior Fellow for Middle East Studies at the Council on Foreign Relations Barbara Slavin Distinguished Fellow at the Stimson Center Michael Doran Senior Fellow and Director of the Center for Peace…
February 20, 2024
Newsletter: Esther Perel on Resolving Conflict in Relationships
Esther Perel Psychotherapist, New York Times Bestselling Author, and Host of the “Where Should We Begin?” Podcast John Donvan Host and Moderator-in-Chief This week: New episode: Esther Perel on how to disagree…
February 12, 2024
MOST READ
Open to Debate Conversation: A New University Offers "Forbidden" Courses
They say that colleges have become too censorious. That our most prestigious institutions have abandoned their mission of fostering critical minds and sparking thoughtful dissent. And that a generation of American students is missing out.…
January 7, 2022
Agree To Disagree COVID Series
Covid is the pandemic threatening our world right now. But the pandemic of misinformation is proving similarly disastrous. Open to Debate brings you “Agree to Disagree: COVID Series,” answering the important questions about the disease…
December 16, 2021
New Podcast: The State Of Debate On Capitol Hill And The American Health Care Act
In this special edition of Open to Debate podcast, we are taking a moment to explore how debates really work in Congress, and to get an insider's perspective on how it has been changing over…
June 27, 2017
Legalize Psychedelics? The Results Are In.
First off, we at Open to Debate would like to extend a warm thank you to all of those who attended and cast their votes during the premier and nationwide broadcasts of our most recent…
April 30, 2021
RESULTS: We Should Expand The Supreme Court
After keeping the vote open for 7 days, the results are in. The team arguing against the motion “We Should Expand The Supreme Court” has emerged as the clear winner. Congratulations to Akhil Reed Amar,…
October 8, 2021
Open To Debate Wins Five Telly Awards
Open to Debate U.S. Wins Record Five Telly Broadcast Awards At the 42nd Annual Telly Awards honoring excellence in video and television across all screens, Open to Debate won five different awards - a personal…
May 27, 2021
The Intelligence Briefing: ‘Twas The Sunday After Christmas
...and all through the House, attention was focused on what Georgia’s voters would espouse. A run-off election to control the other chamber, in a contest that could pit neighbor versus neighbor. Meanwhile, vaccinations continued to…
December 28, 2020
Intelligence Briefing: The Electoral College
This week, the Supreme Court heard arguments (over teleconference) on a case that gets to the heart of a truly unique feature in American democracy: The Electoral College. In this faithless elector case, a group…
March 23, 2022
20 Books To Raise Your IQ This Summer: Our 2020 Summer Reading List
How can you stay sharp this summer? In true Open to Debate fashion, we’re challenging you – our community–to take on a summer reading list with a purpose: bringingnew perspectives to your bookcase. We curated…
June 30, 2020
UP FOR DEBATE: Do Identity Politics Win?
In this week's briefing, we dive into identity politics, break down the GOP’s attraction with African Americans, examine why how we count is before SCOTUS, and of course bring you your Sunday reading list. Enjoy.…
December 14, 2020
What Is The Oxford-Style Debate Format?
The Oxford-style debate format involves a debate on a predetermined statement – also called a “motion” – from two opposing perspectives. The two sides either argue “for” or “against” the motion within a formalized structure.…
January 4, 2019
The Year In Review: The Best Debate Moments Of 2022
2022 has finally ended. Some of it bad, some of it splendid. There was Russia’s invasion. And Ukraine’s self-defense. The west lobbed isolation against Moscow’s offense. This was also the year America closed the door despite…
December 22, 2022
Upcoming Debates
The Pursuit of Happiness: Virtue or Pleasure?
With Roger Crisp, Jeffrey Rosen
10:00 AM | Friday, May 17, 2024
Happiness is a complex emotion and mental state, one that has been pondered since the times of the Ancient Greeks. Many have wondered what it means to be happy and to achieve happiness through either virtue or pleasure. Is it for the good of the individual or the benefit of society? Those who believe virtue is the key to happiness argue that it is important for the well-being of both the individual and society, as touted by the Founding Fathers…
The Pursuit of Happiness: Virtue or Pleasure?
Happiness is a complex emotion and mental state, one that has been pondered since the times of the Ancient Greeks. Many have wondered what it means to be happy and to achieve happiness through either…
With Roger Crisp, Jeffrey Rosen
10:00 AM | Friday, May 17, 2024
DEBATE COMMUNITY
Join a community of social and intellectual leaders that truly value the free exchange of ideas.
EDUCATIONAL BRIEFS
Readings on our weekly debates, debater editorials, and news on issues that affect our everyday lives.
SUPPORT OPEN-MINDED DEBATE
Help us bring debate to communities and classrooms across the nation.