Newsletter: Is Religion a Force for Good?

Is Religion a Force for Good?

ARGUING YES

Shadi Hamid

Columnist and Editorial Board Member of The Washington Post; Assistant Research Professor of Islamic Studies at Fuller Seminary

 


ARGUING NO

Annie Laurie Gaylor

Co-Founder and Co-President of the Freedom From Religion Foundation

 


MODERATOR

John Donvan

Host and Moderator-in-Chief

 


 

This week:

  • New episode: Does religion hurt or help society?
  • A closer look at religion’s influence on American life
  • Your Sunday reading list

 


 

This Sunday, we offer a timely take on an age-old question about faith during a season of religious holidays, including Easter, Passover, and Ramadan and at a time when much is at stake. Antisemitism and Islamophobia have been on an alarming rise worldwide since October 7th. In the United States, studies show that religion will play a key role in the 2024 presidential election.

Religion By the Numbers:

  • The Anti-Defamation League (ADL) reported that antisemitism rose in the U.S. by 388% in the four weeks after October 7, while the Council on American-Islamic Relations reported a 216% rise in Islamophobic incidents.
  • 94% of Americans say it is at least somewhat important to have a president who lives a moral and ethical life.
  • In-person church attendance has increased for the third year in a row to 67%, up from 38% in 2021.
  • Research from Harvard’s School of Public Health shows that women participating in religious services weekly are 68% less likely to die from drug overdose, alcohol poisoning, and suicide.

To help us answer whether religion is a force for good, this episode features esteemed thought leaders from opposite sides of the belief spectrum.

Shadi Hamid is an influential Islamic scholar and columnist for The Washington Post who often writes about religion and its influence on today’s culture. To him, religion makes people happier, more fulfilled, and willing to engage in acts that make society better.

Annie Laurie Gaylor, the co-founder and co-president of the Freedom from Religion Foundation, has spent her career advocating on behalf of people who don’t share religious beliefs and the separation of church and state. She sees religion as a force that creates division and polarization and as an excuse to justify the erosion of individual freedom and social progress.

So, is religion a force for good in a troubled world, or is it sometimes deployed to create more strife? Listen to this debate now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and YouTube and let us know what you think.

 


DEBATING THE DATA
Are Americans moving toward being a secular society?

 

 


POINT/COUNTERPOINT
Is Religion a Force for Good?

 

YES: Shadi Hamid

“As human beings, we all have a religious impulse in the sense we’re all searching for transcendent meaning and purpose. If we’re not going to find it in religion, we’re going to find it in something else. We’ll find it in secular ideologies like communism and fascism… We are social animals, and it is absolutely vital for us to be connected to family, friends, and community. Religion facilitates that. Being part of a religious community helps you develop habits of participation and cooperation. You learn to be part of a collective, of prioritizing something larger than yourself… Religion is a force for good.”

 


NO: Annie Laurie Gaylor

“Religion’s biggest mistake is making dogma more important than people… Many religious people are good… but cruel people believe in a cruel God and use that belief to excuse their cruelty. If someone believes God is giving them marching orders, watch out. Religion encourages believers to spend their best time and energy in pleasing an unprovable God or achieving an unprovable afterlife instead of making this world the paradise that it could be.”

 


WEEKLY POINTS OF VIEW

 


How disinformation fuels violence — and makes our politics worse

Nina Jankowicz | March 26, 2024

The Washington Post

Watch Nina’s debate on information disorder

 


The Prophets: Allan Bloom

Thomas Chatterton Williams | March 30, 2024

The Free Press

Watch Thomas’s debate on whether the classics are overrated

 


American happiness just hit a new low. Don’t blame your parents.

Virginia Heffernan | March 28, 2024

Los Angeles Times

Watch Virginia’s debate on whether the New York Times has lost its way

 


Thank God for the Internal Combustion Engine

Rich Lowry | March 26, 2024

National Review

Watch Rich’s debate on whether to give undocumented immigrants a path to citizenship

 


DEBATE COMMUNITY
Join a community of social and intellectual leaders that truly value the free exchange of ideas.
EDUCATIONAL BRIEFS
Readings on our weekly debates, debater editorials, and news on issues that affect our everyday lives.
SUPPORT OPEN-MINDED DEBATE
Help us bring debate to communities and classrooms across the nation.